The golden age of sandwiches

In their restaurant career sandwiches came from humble beginnings. They could sometimes be found in eating places as far back as the early 1800s, such as at the Ring of Bells, a porter and oyster house in New York. But they became more popular when they teamed up with beer joints after the Civil War. They also flourished in Boston’s “sandwich depots” of the 1880s — bean sandwiches included. And they were among the edibles offered by lunch wagons, saloons, and stand-up buffets in the late 19th century.

But it was the trend toward lighter mid-day meals in the early decades of the 20th century, spurred by the growth of cities, that gave sandwiches their big boost. Then, as light meals replaced hot dinners at noon, they found their niche, furnishing a quickly prepared menu item available in a variety of styles and combinations. Sandwiches of all kinds – named after celebrities, toasted, clubs, St. Paul’s — continued to flourish until after WWII when hamburgers began to take center stage.

While some eating places stuck with hot meals at noon in the early 20th century, others were quick to embrace sandwiches, particularly lunch rooms, tea rooms, drug stores, and delis. The sandwich shop was declared the winner among fast food restaurants. To critics the proliferation of this slapped-together fare was a sign of cultural decline. “The postwar decade might be known as the era of the sandwich,” declared cultural observer Eunice Fuller Barnard in a New York Times article of 1929 with the mournful headline, “We Eat Still, But No Longer Do We Dine.”

Among new developments was the formation of sandwich chains such as the Tasty Toasty and the Hasty Tasty. The B/G System was one of many in that category, which also included R&C, C&L, S&S, and no doubt other alphabetical combos across the USA. In 1924, the “Purely American, Meal in a Minute, No Tipping” B/G chain claimed to pay wages allowing their workers to “live according to American standards.” It had outlets in 16 large cities and was about to spread further. Was St. Louis the champion host of sandwich shops? Included among the city’s 52 sandwich shops in 1938, there were at least 6 “sandwich systems,” the Continental, Hollywood, Nickel Plate, Night Hawk, Ure-Way, and Yankee.

The sandwich selections on the menu shown here are from the Huyler’s confectionery-based chain. Tongue and Cream Cheese sandwiches, rarely (ever?) seen today, were quite popular in those early years (1921 menu above).

Polly’s Cheerio Tea Room’s Ham and Jam on French Toast would seem to be unusual, though perhaps Los Angelenos would have disagreed (1932 menu above).

I can’t account for why Schrafft’s in New York City felt the need to indicate which sandwiches were made with mayonnaise (1938 menu above). I’ve found one other tea room, located in St. Joseph MO, that included the same annotations.

Among the other interesting sandwich combinations I’ve found are Cucumber & Radish (25c at The Cortile in NYC in 1928); Egg and Green Pepper with Mayonnaise on Whole Wheat Gluten Bread (25c at Schrafft’s in 1929); “Chef’s Pride,” Smoked Tongue, Sliced Chicken, and Deviled Eggs double decker (50c at Townsends, San Francisco in1933); Peanut Salad (10c at The Candy Box in Winona MN in 1935); Peanut Butter, Sliced Tomato, Bacon, and Lettuce triple decker on toast (25c at The Little White House in NYC in 1936); and Marshmallow and Peanut Butter (15c at The Bookshop Tearoom in Springfield MA in 1946).

I prefer my BLTs without peanut butter. Hold the marshmallows, please.

© Jan Whitaker, 2021


Filed under food, menus, restaurant customs, tea shops

17 responses to “The golden age of sandwiches

  1. Interesting finds, as usual! From the Bond Bread Cook Book (General Baking Co., 1935), I found the following unusual (by today’s standards) sandwich fillings: ground peanut brittle with butter; peanut butter and grated raw carrots; liver and bacon minced with cream. I’m not sure whether any restaurants served these sandwich fillings but they were suggested for home cooks during the same time period.

  2. ADalton

    The one with French Toast and Jam sounds similar to a Monte Cristo, so I’d try it. But hey, I’m a Los Angeleno.

  3. Janice Ferguson

    I’m sorry, Jan, but the ole fluffernutter (pronounced without a nod to letter “r”) is a definite favorite still in New England. Authentically made with peanut butter and Marshmallow Fluff which has its origins in Lynn, Massachusetts. Show me a kid from New England who hasn’t had a fluffernutter and I’ll show you an imposter!

  4. Pingback: June 2021 Wrap Up – Chasing the Four Winds

  5. Schraft’s noted that their Club Sandwich was made with mayonnaise (the traditional spread for a Club) to assure customers that it wasn’t made with butter (a wholly unnecessary innovation). Also, it was in New York City, where one encounters a significant number of diners who aren’t kosher enough to stick to kosher restaurants, but kosher enough to not want dairy spread on a meat sandwich that usually includes ham 😉

  6. danperlman

    I grew up with peanut butter BLTs, still make them. So much better than without!

  7. Jan: Since you and I are both St. Louisans, I append this to your sandwich “board”. One of my earliest childhood memories is being taken to the Crown Candy Kitchen for lunch with my Dad. There I saw “greasers”, guys with Brylcream in their hair on DA haircuts. The girls wore those wide skirts (But not poodle did I see on them.). And they are worth a word or two from you. Q.V. –

    • Mark, we shall see. I remember going there too!

      • MM Pack

        I actually want to try making a BLT with peanut butter. Mental palate says yes. Of course, I grew up eating peanut butter, mayo, and lettuce sandwiches made by my child -of-the-Depression mother. This was in Houston.

  8. I’m going the opposite way on this: I can see how peanut butter might work on a BLT, especially if it’s natural peanut butter without added sweetener. Might try it when I next have bacon around.

  9. Seth H. Bramson

    And let’s not forget Chicago’s Pixley & Ehlers chain, of which my aunt Gertrude and Uncle Joe’s close friend, Victor West, was VP & GM. And, of course, also in Chicago, Lucy’s and Flo’s on Randolph Street in the Loop; Wimpy’s on Chicago Avenue a bit west of Michigan Avenue and, of course the wonderful Jewish style (seriously equivalent to the best in N Y and/or Miami Beach) Randl’s at Devon and California. Spent many summers there with Aunt Gert and Uncle Joe and for several summers worked at the Acres Motel on N. Lincoln Avenue as lifeguard and swimming instructor. Wonderful and happy memories.

  10. misch brannock

    My gran always took me to Schrafft’s they served cocktails and I could have
    a great hot chocolate with my chicken salad sandwich….good memories

  11. Leslie

    “Marshmallow and Peanut Butter (15c at The Bookshop Tearoom in Springfield MA in 1946)”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.